Water heaters · Help

Water heater help. Start here.

Every guide and free tool we’ve made, in one place. What to do when it leaks, what a code means, whether to fix it or replace it, and what a new one costs. Written by the plumbers who do the work.

Dan and Dave of Dan's Plumbing in front of their work truck

Dan (left) and Dave. Dan's Plumbing, CSLB Lic. #339618, based in Westlake Village. Water heaters are most of what we do.

  • 4 free tools
  • 889 error codes explained
  • 55 town pages

Something’s wrong

Start with what it’s doing

Each guide starts with what to do right now, then what it usually is.

Fix it or replace it?

Dan’s rule of thumb

  1. Water from the tank itself

    The tank has rusted through. No part fixes that, at any age. It’s a new heater.

  2. Older than its usual life, and it needs a real part

    Past about ten years for a tank, fifteen for a tankless. A big repair is money spent on a heater that’s close to done.

  3. Younger than that

    Fix it. Most problems are one part: a thermocouple, a gas valve, an element, a relief valve, a descale.

The full chart: every problem, by age →

Three taps

What kind of water heater?

Then how old it is and what it’s doing. You get the answer Dan would give you on the phone.

What it costs

Prices, out in the open

Our own installed prices and real repair totals, not national averages.

Free tools

Look it up yourself

No sign-up, no email. Type and go.

Age lookup

How old is my water heater?

The date is hidden in the serial number on the label. Type it in and see the month and year it was made.

Water hardness

How hard is your water?

Your water supplier’s hardness by ZIP code, and what it means for a water heater.

Error codes

What does my code mean?

Pick the brand on the label. 889 codes, each in plain words.

Type in your code →

Repair or replace

Fix it, or get a new one?

What kind, how old, what it’s doing. Three taps, then Dan’s answer, plus the full chart.

Start the three taps

How it works

The parts of a gas water heater

Tap a number to see what the part does and what goes wrong with it.

A gas tank water heater with eleven numbered parts: the cold water shutoff, expansion tank, relief valve, earthquake straps, anode rod, label, dip tube, gas control, pilot and burner, drain valve and drain pan. HOT VENT COLD GAS 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
A gas tank. An electric tank has two heating elements and thermostats in place of the burner and gas control. A tankless is a box on the wall: see tankless.
  1. Cold water shutoff

    The valve on the pipe going in. Turn it off if the tank leaks, and no more water goes in. If it’s leaking →

  2. Expansion tank

    Gives heated water room to grow. With a pressure regulator it’s required, or the relief valve drips. Water pressure →

  3. Relief valve and its drain line

    Opens if the pressure or heat gets too high. A steady drip usually means high water pressure. Repairs →

  4. Earthquake straps

    Two straps, one in the top third and one in the bottom third. California requires them. In every install →

  5. Anode rod (inside)

    A metal rod that rusts so the tank doesn’t. When it’s used up: rusty hot water or a rotten-egg smell. Fix or replace? →

  6. The label

    Brand, model and serial number. The serial number tells you how old the heater is. How old is it? →

  7. Dip tube (inside)

    Carries the cold water to the bottom. If it breaks, the hot water runs out fast. Fix or replace? →

  8. Gas control and status light

    Sets the temperature. On many tanks the light blinks a code when something’s wrong. Blinking light? →

  9. Pilot, thermocouple and burner

    Behind the cover. A pilot that won’t stay lit is often the thermocouple, the part that keeps it lit. No hot water? →

  10. Drain valve

    For flushing out sediment. Hard water fills the bottom of the tank fast. Your water’s hardness →

  11. Drain pan

    Catches small leaks so you see them early. What a leak means →

From the jobsite

Real water heater jobs, real totals

Every job on the blog →

An error code that kept coming back.

A Thousand Oaks tankless heater kept showing an error code. Dan and Dave flushed it first, then found a leak in the heat exchanger and put in a new tankless heater and vent. $6,695.46.

$6,695.46 job totalSee the work →

Common questions

Quick answers

My water heater is leaking. What do I do first?

Shut off the cold water valve on the pipe going into the top of the tank. Then turn off the heat: the gas knob to OFF, or the breaker on an electric heater. Catch the water with a bucket and towels, and text Dan a photo of where it’s coming from and the label.

How long does a water heater last?

A tank, gas or electric, usually lasts 8 to 12 years around here. Our hard water pushes it toward the low end. A tankless can run 15 to 20 years or more with a yearly descale.

Should I repair or replace my water heater?

Water coming out of the tank itself means a new heater at any age. A tank past about ten years that needs a real part is usually better replaced. Younger than that, fix it. Our repair-or-replace tool gives Dan’s answer in three taps.

What does the code on my water heater mean?

It depends on the brand: code 11 on a Rinnai isn’t the same as 11 on a Noritz. Look it up by brand in our error code library, which explains each code in plain words from the maker’s own manual.

How much is a new water heater?

A standard 50-gallon gas tank is $2,950 installed, with straps, an expansion tank, a drain pan, new connectors and haul-away. Sales tax on the parts is extra.

Towns we cover

Water heater help near you

Anywhere within about 30 miles of the shop in Westlake Village. Same prices everywhere.

Our shop 30 miles. Tap a dot to open that town.
Dan standing in front of his white work truck, smiling

Still stuck?

Text Dan a photo of the label and what it’s doing. He’ll tell you what it likely is, and whether it’s worth fixing.

Or send the details and Dan will call you back. Monday to Friday, 9am – 5pm.

Find us

Dan's Plumbing

2352 Hillsbury Rd
Westlake Village, CA 91361

(805) 330-3111 · Monday to Friday, 9am – 5pm

Serving Westlake Village, Thousand Oaks, Agoura Hills, Oak Park and Lake Sherwood. Zip codes 91361, 91362, 91360, 91320, 91301, 91377, 91302, 90265.

Dan (left) and Dave. Family run since 1977. One of them does the work.